Alder Lane asks you to choose between a blanket discount and a targeted offer for one product. The warehouse can supply either plan. Existing fixed costs don't change. Compare each plan with baseline contribution, include discounts on existing sales and campaign costs, then choose a testable recommendation. All data are fictional.
Continue with spoken case practice in the Interview Hub.
A promotion can sell more units and reduce profit.
Start with the sales that would happen without it. A blanket discount gives up margin on those sales as well as on the extra units. Campaign costs come out afterward.
Alder Lane sells one product and can serve the proposed demand without extra fixed costs. Its commercial director offers two plans: a discount for everyone, or a targeted offer to new buyers. Compare each against the same baseline. For the targeted offer, separate genuinely new sales from existing customers who receive a discount. Your recommendation must use incremental contribution and state how the retailer will test whether those buyers are really incremental.
Higher volume doesn't guarantee higher contribution.