Critical reasoning: strengthen
Which of the following, if true, most strongly supports the bookstore chain's expectation?
A bookstore chain plans to place handwritten cards with staff recommendations beneath selected titles. The chain expects sales of those titles to rise, reasoning that browsing customers are drawn to books that a real person has vouched for.
- Many customers who browse in the chain's stores later buy their books online from other sellers.
- The chain's staff members read, on average, many more books each year than the chain's customers do.
- In a four-store trial, carded titles outsold the same titles at stores that had no cards.
- Publishers sometimes pay bookstores to display particular titles on tables near the entrance.
- Handwritten cards cost the chain very little to produce and to replace with new ones each month.
Answer: c
The chain predicts that the cards will raise sales. A trial in which the same titles sold better only where cards were placed is direct evidence for that causal claim.
Source: GMAT Focus Verbal Reasoning content (mba.com): Critical Reasoning gives a short argument and asks which of five options strengthens or weakens it, explains a flaw, or what it supports. The argument is original and fictional.; GMAC exam overview: Verbal Reasoning is 45 minutes and 23 questions and assesses critical reasoning and reading comprehension.
Critical reasoning: assumption
The argument about science laboratories depends on which of the following assumptions?
Nearly every winner of the regional science fair over the past decade attended a school with a dedicated science laboratory. The district should therefore build laboratories at its schools that lack them, since doing so will increase the number of its students who win the fair.
- Every school that receives a new laboratory will use it for all of its science classes.
- The judges at the science fair are not told which school each of the entrants attends.
- The winners' success is not due mainly to other advantages their schools have over the rest.
- Students at schools without laboratories have entered the science fair in past years.
- Building laboratories is the cheapest way to improve the district's science teaching.
Answer: c
The argument moves from a correlation (winners come from schools with labs) to a causal prediction. It must assume that the labs, not some other advantage of those schools such as funding or staff, account for the winners. If that assumption is false, the plan no longer follows.
Source: GMAT Focus Verbal Reasoning content (mba.com): Critical Reasoning gives a short argument and asks which of five options strengthens or weakens it, explains a flaw, or what it supports. The argument is original and fictional.; GMAC exam overview: Verbal Reasoning is 45 minutes and 23 questions and assesses critical reasoning and reading comprehension.
Critical reasoning: evaluate
Which of the following would it be most useful to establish in order to evaluate the Grafton County officials' conclusion?
Two years ago Grafton County began offering free bus passes to residents over 65. Since then, the number of traffic accidents involving drivers over 65 in the county has fallen by a fifth. County officials conclude that the passes reduced such accidents by persuading older residents to drive less.
- Whether residents over 65 drove fewer total miles after the passes were introduced
- How the county raised the money it needed to pay for the free bus passes
- Whether residents under 65 have asked the county to give them free passes too
- Whether the county's buses have a better safety record than the county's taxis
- Whether the printed design of the passes was changed during the second year
Answer: a
The officials' mechanism is that the passes made older residents drive less. Knowing whether their miles driven actually fell tests that mechanism directly: a fall supports it, and no change suggests some other cause of the drop in accidents.
Source: GMAT Focus Verbal Reasoning content (mba.com): Critical Reasoning gives a short argument and asks which of five options strengthens or weakens it, explains a flaw, or what it supports. The argument is original and fictional.; GMAC exam overview: Verbal Reasoning is 45 minutes and 23 questions and assesses critical reasoning and reading comprehension.
Critical reasoning: inference
If the statements about the Hollins plant are true, which of the following must also be true?
At the Hollins plant, every machine that failed last quarter's safety inspection was more than ten years old. Some machines more than ten years old passed that inspection. Every machine that fails a safety inspection is taken out of service until it is repaired.
- Every machine taken out of service for failing last quarter's inspection was over ten years old.
- Most of the plant's machines that are more than ten years old failed last quarter's inspection.
- No machine at the plant that passed last quarter's inspection is now out of service for any reason.
- Some of the plant's machines that are ten years old or newer were not inspected last quarter.
- Some machines that were taken out of service last quarter were ten years old or newer.
Answer: a
Only machines over ten years old failed the inspection, and every failing machine is taken out of service. So any machine removed because it failed that inspection must have been over ten years old. Nothing is known about proportions or about removals for other reasons.
Source: GMAT Focus Verbal Reasoning content (mba.com): Critical Reasoning gives a short argument and asks which of five options strengthens or weakens it, explains a flaw, or what it supports. The argument is original and fictional.; GMAC exam overview: Verbal Reasoning is 45 minutes and 23 questions and assesses critical reasoning and reading comprehension.
Critical reasoning: roles in an argument
In the argument about the Harbor Bridge toll, the two portions in square brackets play which of the following roles?
Some analysts predict that [the new toll on the Harbor Bridge will push many commuters onto the free Ridge Road], worsening congestion there. But most bridge commuters are headed for the business district, and taking Ridge Road adds about forty minutes to that trip. [Few commuters are likely to accept such a delay to avoid a modest toll], so congestion on Ridge Road is unlikely to rise by much.
- The first is a prediction that the argument disputes; the second is the main conclusion of the argument.
- The first is a prediction that the argument disputes; the second is a judgment that supports its conclusion.
- The first is the main conclusion of the argument; the second is evidence offered in support of that conclusion.
- The first is evidence the argument relies on; the second is a consideration weighing against its conclusion.
- The first and the second are both predictions made by the analysts whose view the argument opposes.
Answer: b
The argument opposes the analysts' prediction (first portion). Its main conclusion follows "so": congestion on Ridge Road is unlikely to rise much. The second portion, that few commuters will accept a forty-minute delay, is the judgment from which that conclusion is drawn.
Source: GMAT Focus Verbal Reasoning content (mba.com): Critical Reasoning gives a short argument and asks which of five options strengthens or weakens it, explains a flaw, or what it supports. The argument is original and fictional.; GMAC exam overview: Verbal Reasoning is 45 minutes and 23 questions and assesses critical reasoning and reading comprehension.
Critical reasoning: paradox
Which of the following, if true, most helps to explain the fall in Dorrance Hardware's power tool revenue?
After Dorrance Hardware cut the prices of all its power tools by 15 percent, the number of power tools it sold rose by 30 percent compared with the same months of the year before. Yet the store's total revenue from power tools fell.
- Several competing stores in the area also cut their prices on power tools during the same months.
- Dorrance advertised the price cut widely, both in local newspapers and on social media sites.
- Sales of hand tools and other hardware at Dorrance also rose during the same months of the year.
- After the cut, buyers chose far more cheap tools and far fewer costly ones.
- Dorrance's profit margin on each power tool it sold was lower after the price cut than before it.
Answer: d
With the same mix of tools, a 15 percent cut and 30 percent more units would raise revenue: 0.85 × 1.30 = 1.105, about 10.5 percent more. Revenue falls only if the average price per tool sold dropped below 1 ÷ 1.30, about 77 percent of its old level (a drop of more than 23 percent), which a shift toward the cheapest tools can produce.
Source: GMAT Focus Verbal Reasoning content (mba.com): Critical Reasoning gives a short argument and asks which of five options strengthens or weakens it, explains a flaw, or what it supports. The argument is original and fictional.; GMAC exam overview: Verbal Reasoning is 45 minutes and 23 questions and assesses critical reasoning and reading comprehension.
Critical reasoning: flaw
The reasoning in council member Arden's argument is most vulnerable to criticism on the grounds that it
Council member Arden urges the town to reject the plan to repave Elm Street that her rival, Mr. Voss, has proposed. Mr. Voss, she points out, has missed more council meetings this year than any other member and plainly takes the town's business lightly.
- assumes that a plan must be a good one simply because many people support it
- treats one event as the cause of another simply because the first came earlier
- draws a broad general conclusion from a small and unrepresentative sample
- attacks the person who made a proposal instead of the merits of the proposal
- relies on an analogy between two situations that differ in important ways
Answer: d
Arden urges rejecting the plan because of Voss's record at meetings. That is a criticism of the person, not of the plan; the plan could be sound whatever its sponsor's attendance.
Source: GMAT Focus Verbal Reasoning content (mba.com): Critical Reasoning gives a short argument and asks which of five options strengthens or weakens it, explains a flaw, or what it supports. The argument is original and fictional.; GMAC exam overview: Verbal Reasoning is 45 minutes and 23 questions and assesses critical reasoning and reading comprehension.
Critical reasoning: assumption
The researchers' conclusion about giving dogs to inactive adults depends on which of the following assumptions?
Researchers found that people who own dogs walk, on average, considerably more each day than people who do not. The researchers concluded that a program that gave dogs to inactive adults would increase the amount those adults walk each day.
- Most people who own dogs take their dogs out for a walk at least twice every day.
- Inactive adults would, in general, prefer being given a dog to being given a cat.
- A dog program would cost less than other programs that encourage people to exercise.
- Owners' extra walking is not wholly due to active people being likelier to get dogs.
- People who do not own dogs seldom walk for any reason other than getting to work.
Answer: d
The study shows a correlation between owning a dog and walking. To predict that giving dogs to inactive adults will raise their walking, the researchers must assume that owning a dog causes at least some of the extra walking, rather than walkers choosing dogs. If that assumption fails, the program would do nothing.
Source: GMAT Focus Verbal Reasoning content (mba.com): Critical Reasoning gives a short argument and asks which of five options strengthens or weakens it, explains a flaw, or what it supports. The argument is original and fictional.; GMAC exam overview: Verbal Reasoning is 45 minutes and 23 questions and assesses critical reasoning and reading comprehension.
Critical reasoning: strengthen
Which of the following, if true, most strengthens the software company managers' conclusion?
In a study of 40 software teams at one company, teams whose members worked in the same office finished their projects faster, on average, than teams whose members worked in different cities. The company's managers concluded that placing team members in the same office speeds up project completion.
- The projects given to the two kinds of teams were similar in size and in difficulty.
- Some members of the same-office teams worked from home on one day of every week.
- Members of the teams spread across cities held video meetings several times each week.
- Most of the company's employees say they prefer working in an office to working remotely.
- The company plans to open new offices in several cities where its remote staff live.
Answer: a
An obvious alternative explanation is that same-office teams got smaller or easier projects. If projects were similar in size and difficulty, that alternative is ruled out, and the office arrangement becomes the more likely cause.
Source: GMAT Focus Verbal Reasoning content (mba.com): Critical Reasoning gives a short argument and asks which of five options strengthens or weakens it, explains a flaw, or what it supports. The argument is original and fictional.; GMAC exam overview: Verbal Reasoning is 45 minutes and 23 questions and assesses critical reasoning and reading comprehension.
Critical reasoning: weaken
Which of the following, if true, most seriously weakens the marketing director's conclusion about Ridgeline boots?
A survey of readers of Trail & Summit, a hiking magazine, found that 70 percent own at least one pair of Ridgeline hiking boots. Ridgeline's marketing director concludes that most hikers in the country own Ridgeline boots.
- Trail & Summit has more readers than any other hiking magazine published in the country.
- Ridgeline also makes tents and backpacks, which sell well among the magazine's readers.
- Many hikers own more than one pair of hiking boots, often made by different companies.
- Readers who own Ridgeline boots gave them high ratings for comfort in the same survey.
- For ten years Ridgeline has advertised heavily in Trail & Summit and almost nowhere else.
Answer: e
The conclusion generalizes from the magazine's readers to all hikers. If those readers are the audience Ridgeline targets almost exclusively, they are likely to own its boots at a higher rate than hikers generally, so the sample is unrepresentative.
Source: GMAT Focus Verbal Reasoning content (mba.com): Critical Reasoning gives a short argument and asks which of five options strengthens or weakens it, explains a flaw, or what it supports. The argument is original and fictional.; GMAC exam overview: Verbal Reasoning is 45 minutes and 23 questions and assesses critical reasoning and reading comprehension.
Critical reasoning: evaluate
Which of the following would be most useful to know in evaluating the Brenford officials' argument?
The town of Brenford plans to replace its gas-powered leaf blowers with battery-powered ones. Battery-powered blowers cost more to buy, but town officials argue that the switch will save money over the life of the equipment, because electricity for charging costs far less than gasoline.
- Whether residents of Brenford prefer the quieter sound of battery-powered blowers
- Whether several neighboring towns have also switched to battery-powered blowers
- Whether the town's crews were consulted before the switch was publicly announced
- Whether the new blowers are made by the same company that made the old blowers
- How long the new blowers last and what their replacement batteries cost
Answer: e
The officials weigh a higher purchase price against lower fuel costs. Whether the switch saves money "over the life of the equipment" also depends on how long the new blowers last and what replacing their batteries costs, which the argument ignores.
Source: GMAT Focus Verbal Reasoning content (mba.com): Critical Reasoning gives a short argument and asks which of five options strengthens or weakens it, explains a flaw, or what it supports. The argument is original and fictional.; GMAC exam overview: Verbal Reasoning is 45 minutes and 23 questions and assesses critical reasoning and reading comprehension.
Critical reasoning: inference
If the statements about Velmar are true, which of the following must be true?
In Velmar, a person can be elected to the national council only if he or she has lived in Velmar for at least ten years. Everyone who has lived in Velmar for at least ten years is entitled to vote there. Some people entitled to vote in Velmar were born abroad.
- Some of the members of Velmar's national council were born abroad.
- Everyone entitled to vote in Velmar has lived there for at least ten years.
- No one who was born abroad can be elected to Velmar's national council.
- Some people who are entitled to vote in Velmar cannot be elected to its council.
- Everyone elected to Velmar's national council is entitled to vote there.
Answer: e
Being elected requires at least ten years' residence (first statement), and ten years' residence brings the right to vote (second statement). Chaining the two, every elected member is entitled to vote. The other options reverse a conditional or go beyond the facts.
Source: GMAT Focus Verbal Reasoning content (mba.com): Critical Reasoning gives a short argument and asks which of five options strengthens or weakens it, explains a flaw, or what it supports. The argument is original and fictional.; GMAC exam overview: Verbal Reasoning is 45 minutes and 23 questions and assesses critical reasoning and reading comprehension.
Critical reasoning: roles in an argument
In the argument about the Main Street bike lanes, the two portions in square brackets play which of the following roles?
Critics of the city's plan to turn two car lanes on Main Street into bike lanes argue that [the change will hurt the street's shops by making it harder for customers to arrive by car]. Yet surveys show that fewer than a third of Main Street's shoppers arrive by car, and that those who come on foot or by bicycle visit more often. [The plan is therefore unlikely to harm the street's businesses and may well help them.]
- The first is evidence offered for the second; the second is the main conclusion of the argument.
- The first is a claim the argument opposes; the second is evidence offered against that claim.
- The first is the main conclusion of the argument; the second is a consideration that supports it.
- The first and the second are both claims made by the critics of the city's bike lane plan.
- The first is a claim the argument opposes; the second is the main conclusion of the argument.
Answer: e
The critics' claim (first portion) is introduced to be answered. The surveys are the evidence, and "therefore" introduces the second portion as the conclusion the argument draws against the critics.
Source: GMAT Focus Verbal Reasoning content (mba.com): Critical Reasoning gives a short argument and asks which of five options strengthens or weakens it, explains a flaw, or what it supports. The argument is original and fictional.; GMAC exam overview: Verbal Reasoning is 45 minutes and 23 questions and assesses critical reasoning and reading comprehension.
Critical reasoning: paradox
Which of the following, if true, most helps to resolve the apparent discrepancy in the figures for Rosk?
In the country of Rosk, the share of adults who smoke has fallen steadily over the past twenty years. Over the same period, the number of new cases of lung cancer diagnosed in Rosk each year has risen.
- Most smokers in Rosk who quit during the period did so on the advice of their own doctors.
- Taxes on cigarettes in Rosk were raised several times during the past twenty years.
- People in Rosk who quit smoking face a much lower risk of lung cancer than those who keep on smoking.
- Lung cancer usually appears decades after smoking, and Rosk's many ex-smokers are now that age.
- The share of adults in Rosk who drink alcohol also fell steadily over the same twenty years.
Answer: d
The puzzle sets a current behavior (fewer smokers now) against an outcome that lags it by decades. If the disease mostly strikes people who smoked heavily long ago and many such people are now at the ages of highest risk, new cases can rise while the smoking rate falls.
Source: GMAT Focus Verbal Reasoning content (mba.com): Critical Reasoning gives a short argument and asks which of five options strengthens or weakens it, explains a flaw, or what it supports. The argument is original and fictional.; GMAC exam overview: Verbal Reasoning is 45 minutes and 23 questions and assesses critical reasoning and reading comprehension.
Critical reasoning: assumption
Which of the following is an assumption on which the argument about Kemper Logistics depends?
Kemper Logistics should move its warehouse from the city center to the industrial park outside town. Rent at the industrial park is 40 percent lower than Kemper pays now, so the move will reduce Kemper's operating costs.
- The industrial park has room for Kemper to expand its warehouse in the coming years.
- The rent saved will not be outweighed by higher costs elsewhere, such as longer routes.
- Rents in the city center will keep rising steadily over the next several years.
- Several other logistics firms have already moved their warehouses to the park.
- Most of Kemper's employees would rather work outside the city center than in it.
Answer: b
Rent is one cost among many. The conclusion that total operating costs will fall requires that other costs, like fuel and driver time on longer routes, do not rise enough to cancel the rent savings.
Source: GMAT Focus Verbal Reasoning content (mba.com): Critical Reasoning gives a short argument and asks which of five options strengthens or weakens it, explains a flaw, or what it supports. The argument is original and fictional.; GMAC exam overview: Verbal Reasoning is 45 minutes and 23 questions and assesses critical reasoning and reading comprehension.
Critical reasoning: strengthen
Which of the following, if true, most strengthens the gardener's conclusion about her tomato plants?
A gardener noticed that the tomato plants in the part of her garden shaded in the afternoon produced fewer tomatoes than the plants in full sun. She concluded that the afternoon shade reduced the yield of the shaded plants.
- Tomato plants generally need to be watered every day during the hottest weeks of summer.
- The gardener plans to move some of the shaded tomato plants into full sun next year.
- Both beds have the same soil, and all the plants were watered and fed in the same way.
- Neighbors who grow their tomatoes in full sun also had a good harvest this year.
- The plants in the shaded bed grew taller than the plants in the sunny bed this year.
Answer: c
The gardener infers cause from a difference between two beds. Showing that the beds were alike in soil, water, and feeding removes the main rival explanations, so the remaining difference, shade, becomes the likely cause.
Source: GMAT Focus Verbal Reasoning content (mba.com): Critical Reasoning gives a short argument and asks which of five options strengthens or weakens it, explains a flaw, or what it supports. The argument is original and fictional.; GMAC exam overview: Verbal Reasoning is 45 minutes and 23 questions and assesses critical reasoning and reading comprehension.
Critical reasoning: weaken
Which of the following, if true, most seriously weakens the SkyLink managers' explanation?
Since the regional airline SkyLink began publishing its monthly on-time performance, the share of its flights arriving on time has risen from 78 percent to 89 percent. SkyLink's managers credit the improvement to the pressure that public reporting puts on the airline's operations staff.
- SkyLink publishes the monthly figures both on its website and in its in-flight magazine.
- Most of SkyLink's passengers are business travelers who place a high value on punctuality.
- Several larger airlines had higher on-time rates than SkyLink even before it began publishing.
- Just before it began publishing, SkyLink added 15 to 20 minutes to most flights' schedules.
- The industry's definition of an on-time arrival did not change at any point during the period.
Answer: d
If scheduled flight times were lengthened, more flights would arrive "on time" even if operations were unchanged. That alternative cause explains the jump without any pressure from public reporting.
Source: GMAT Focus Verbal Reasoning content (mba.com): Critical Reasoning gives a short argument and asks which of five options strengthens or weakens it, explains a flaw, or what it supports. The argument is original and fictional.; GMAC exam overview: Verbal Reasoning is 45 minutes and 23 questions and assesses critical reasoning and reading comprehension.
Critical reasoning: evaluate
Which of the following would be most useful to determine in evaluating the library board's conclusion?
A city library extended the weekday closing time of its central branch from 6 p.m. to 9 p.m. Over the next year, visits to the central branch rose by 18 percent. The library board concludes that longer hours attract more visitors and plans to extend hours at every branch.
- How much the library spends on new books for the central branch in a typical year
- Whether most of the additional visits took place between 6 p.m. and 9 p.m.
- Whether library cards are issued free of charge to all residents of the city
- Whether staff at the central branch would rather work evening or morning shifts
- How many books visitors to the central branch borrow on an average visit
Answer: b
If the extra visits came in the added evening hours, longer hours are a plausible cause. If they came during the day, something else, such as a new program or population growth, probably drove the rise, and extending hours elsewhere might not help.
Source: GMAT Focus Verbal Reasoning content (mba.com): Critical Reasoning gives a short argument and asks which of five options strengthens or weakens it, explains a flaw, or what it supports. The argument is original and fictional.; GMAC exam overview: Verbal Reasoning is 45 minutes and 23 questions and assesses critical reasoning and reading comprehension.
Critical reasoning: flaw
Which of the following most accurately describes a flaw in the business consultant's reasoning?
A survey of the shops that have operated on Carver Street for at least five years found that every one of them is profitable. A business consultant concludes that a new shop opening on Carver Street is very likely to be profitable.
- It assumes that profit is the only measure of whether a shop is a success.
- It fails to state how large the profits of the surveyed shops actually are.
- It ignores shops that closed before they had operated for five years.
- It treats the profitability of the shops as the cause of where they are located.
- It relies on the judgment of a consultant who may be biased toward the street.
Answer: c
Only shops that lasted five years were surveyed. Shops that failed sooner are invisible, so the sample is biased toward success and says little about the chances of a new shop.
Source: GMAT Focus Verbal Reasoning content (mba.com): Critical Reasoning gives a short argument and asks which of five options strengthens or weakens it, explains a flaw, or what it supports. The argument is original and fictional.; GMAC exam overview: Verbal Reasoning is 45 minutes and 23 questions and assesses critical reasoning and reading comprehension.
Critical reasoning: inference
If the statements about Fenwick's employees are true, which of the following must also be true?
Every employee at Fenwick who works in sales has completed the company's negotiation course. No one who has completed the negotiation course is eligible for the introductory mentoring program. Some employees in Fenwick's design department are eligible for the introductory mentoring program.
- No employee in Fenwick's design department has completed the negotiation course.
- Every employee eligible for the mentoring program works in the design department.
- Some employees in the design department do not work in sales.
- Some employees in sales are eligible for the introductory mentoring program.
- Every employee in the design department is eligible for the mentoring program.
Answer: c
Sales staff have all completed the course, and course completers are not eligible. So no sales employee is eligible. Some design employees are eligible, so those employees cannot work in sales.
Source: GMAT Focus Verbal Reasoning content (mba.com): Critical Reasoning gives a short argument and asks which of five options strengthens or weakens it, explains a flaw, or what it supports. The argument is original and fictional.; GMAC exam overview: Verbal Reasoning is 45 minutes and 23 questions and assesses critical reasoning and reading comprehension.