A deal ends in Closed won or Closed lost. Closing is not the end of the record's job: win rates, sales cycles and revenue reports all read closed deals, so close them carefully.
Set the Close date to the day it actually closed; reports put revenue in that month. For a lost deal, record the Closed lost reason in the same words your team uses every time ("Chose a competitor", not "competitor" today and "went with X" tomorrow), or the reasons can't be counted.
Never delete a lost deal: it is part of your win rate. If the customer comes back, reopen the deal by moving it to an open stage and clear the lost reason, or create a new deal if it is a new purchase.