With acks=all, a producer waits for the current in-sync replicas required by the broker policy. min.insync.replicas sets the minimum ISR size needed to accept that write. Replication factor describes the desired copies; ISR describes the replicas currently caught up. Three assigned replicas with only one in sync are not the same durability state as three healthy copies. These tasks retain the two-copy requirement while one broker is down. Configure the topic and producer together, then publish the record. Lowering the minimum may make an error disappear, but it changes the guarantee the business requested. The model advances replication explicitly so that difference stays visible.
Inspect the topics, partition logs and group offsets before changing the cluster.