An ordinary consumer group assigns each partition to at most one active member at a time. Adding a member redistributes assignments; adding more members than partitions leaves some idle. Different groups do not share that assignment limit with each other. A rebalance can move work, so processing and offset commits must tolerate a partition being revoked. This model uses a deterministic sorted-member assignment rather than implementing every assignor or the network coordination protocol. The tasks make that boundary visible by asking for one partition per member. Inspect the resulting assignments, not just the member count. Three consumers accidentally created in three groups would read three copies of the subscription.
Inspect the topics, partition logs and group offsets before changing the cluster.