An offset is a position inside one partition, not a global record number for the topic. Offset zero identifies the first appended record. Offset one identifies the next position, even though people often call it the second record. Compaction and retention can leave gaps, so offsets are not a reliable count of surviving records. The console consumer can select a partition, starting offset and maximum number of messages. Use those controls to inspect one requested record without changing the log. A bounded read makes an investigation easier to explain and avoids mistaking an empty future position for lost data. Check the returned offset, not just the payload.
Inspect the topics, partition logs and group offsets before changing the cluster.