Ask one question first: was the claim right?
- No, the claim had an error (wrong code, missing modifier, wrong member ID): correct it and resubmit as a corrected or replacement claim, with the original claim number, following the payer's rules. Sending it again as a new claim gets a duplicate denial. Medicare returns claims with missing or invalid data as unprocessable, without appeal rights: fix and resubmit; a simple clerical error on a processed claim can be reopened.
- Yes, and the payer disagrees (medical necessity, level of care, documentation): appeal, with the records that show why.
- The provider is at fault and cannot fix it (deadline missed): write it off. The patient is billed only when the plan says the amount is the patient's, or a valid notice made the patient liable.
Medicare appeals have five levels: 1) redetermination by the Medicare Administrative Contractor, requested within 120 days of receiving the initial determination (receipt is presumed 5 days after the notice date); 2) reconsideration by a Qualified Independent Contractor, within 180 days of receiving the redetermination; 3) a hearing before an Administrative Law Judge; 4) review by the Medicare Appeals Council; 5) federal district court. Levels 3 and 5 need a minimum amount in dispute, set every year.
An appeal letter names the patient, the claim and the service, says what was denied and why the denial is wrong, cites the rule or policy, and encloses the records that prove it.