A duplicate is the same case reported more than once. Duplicates matter because they make signals look stronger than they are (ICH E2D(R1)). Common causes:
- a consumer and a health professional reporting the same event;
- several health professionals treating the same patient;
- the reporter telling both the company and the regulator;
- the same article reported by several companies.
Before creating a new case, search the database. A match is judged on similarities: the patient (initials, age, sex), the product, the event, the dates. Details can differ between reporters: a son may say his mother is "about 70" when her doctor writes 71. Missing a duplicate because one detail differs is a common mistake; so is merging two different patients because one detail matches.
When a duplicate is found:
- New information goes into the existing case as a follow-up.
- E2B(R3) records other identifiers the case is known by (C.1.9.1), and lets the sender nullify a case (C.1.11.1, value 1) or amend it (value 2).
- GVP Module VI: nullification is for a case that is wholly erroneous or a duplicate; the reason must be clear and specific; only the organisation that sent the case can nullify it; and a nullified case cannot be reactivated. If it has to be sent again, it gets a new case identifier (E2B(R3) C.1.1 and C.1.8.1).
- For literature, check whether the article's case is already in the database (GVP VI.App.2.8). If it is, add the citation to the existing case and send a follow-up (ICH E2D(R1)).