A report becomes a valid case (an individual case safety report, ICSR, that can be submitted) when it has four things. ICH E2D(R1) and EU GVP Module VI list them:
- at least one identifiable reporter;
- an identifiable patient;
- at least one suspect (or interacting) medicinal product;
- at least one adverse event or reaction.
Nothing else is needed for validity: not the dates, not the dose, not the outcome, not a doctor's opinion on causality. Those are collected too, but a report with the four criteria is a valid case on the day they are known, and that day starts the reporting clock.
When one criterion is missing, the report is incomplete. It is not submitted as an ICSR, but it is not thrown away either: it is recorded in the safety database and the company follows up with due diligence to collect what is missing, documenting each attempt.
The four minimum criteria.