There are four common ways to estimate cost or duration:
- Analogous (top-down): start from a similar past project and adjust. Quick and cheap, but only as good as the similarity.
- Parametric: multiply a unit rate by a quantity: square feet × cost per square foot, records × minutes per record. Accurate when the rate really applies at this scale.
- Bottom-up: estimate every work package and add them up. The most accurate and the most work; it needs a detailed WBS.
- Expert judgment: ask people who have done it. Often combined with the others.
Early in a project, when little is defined, analogous estimates give a range for the go or no-go decision. As the WBS fills in, bottom-up estimates replace them.
The classic trap is a parametric rate that does not scale: a painting rate measured on small rooms does not hold for a hall that needs scaffolding.
Three estimates for the same project, at different stages.