A connected data source doesn't mean every record belongs in the current batch. Edit the recipient list before you merge. A paused membership should not receive a renewal letter merely because it sits between two renewing records.
Use the recipient selection or a filter, then turn on Preview Results. Preview shows data in the main document; it doesn't create the finished recipient documents. Check at least a record with an optional blank, because a missing town can leave awkward wording or punctuation in a letter. The model keeps recipient indexes stable in the source list. When a task names records 1 and 3, those are the first and third visible source records, stored as indexes 0 and 2. Read names as well as positions.
The batch includes the two renewals and excludes the paused record.