CAT Verbal ability and reading comprehension practice, set 1
14 questions on verbal ability and reading comprehension at CAT pace: 25 min on the clock, or none if you want to study.
- Questions
- 14
- Time
- 25 min
- To pass
- 7 (50%)
- Part
- Verbal ability and reading comprehension
- Mode
- Timed or untimed
- Access
- Free
The practice test needs JavaScript. These are its questions:
The commons revisited
In 1968 the ecologist Garrett Hardin published an essay in the journal Science that gave a generation of policy makers a ready-made story. Picture a pasture open to all, he wrote, and a set of herders each deciding whether to add one more animal to the herd. The herder who adds an animal keeps the whole gain from it, while the cost of the extra grazing is spread across everyone. Each herder, reasoning sensibly, adds another animal, and then another, until the pasture is ruined. The parable was not new: the economist William Forster Lloyd had used grazing cattle to make a similar point in 1833. But Hardin's phrase, the tragedy of the commons, stuck, and so did his conclusion. A shared resource, he suggested, could be saved only by turning it into private property or by placing it under the control of the state. The difficulty with the parable is that its herders do not speak to one another. They have no history, no reputation to protect and no means of watching what their neighbours do. Elinor Ostrom, the political scientist who in 2009 became the first woman to receive the Nobel Memorial Prize in Economic Sciences, spent decades studying what happens when real people face this situation. She and her colleagues examined irrigation canals, inshore fisheries, village forests and mountain pastures on several continents, some of them managed by the same communities for generations. What she found was neither the ruin Hardin predicted nor a romantic harmony. Many commons failed. Many others lasted, and the ones that lasted tended to share certain features. The people who drew on the resource could say clearly who belonged and who did not. The rules about how much each could take had been shaped by those who had to live with them, and fitted the local conditions of soil, water and season. Members watched one another, often cheaply and as part of ordinary work, and a person caught breaking a rule faced a penalty that started small and grew with repetition. Disputes could be settled quickly, close to home, without an expensive appeal to a distant court. None of this makes the commons a model for every problem. Ostrom was careful to say that her principles described conditions under which cooperation became more likely, not a recipe that guaranteed it. A fishing village whose members meet every week is a different thing from the atmosphere, which is shared by billions of people who will never meet. Yet her work removed the grounds for a lazy choice between only two options. The real question, she argued, is not whether a resource should belong to the market or to the government, but which arrangement of rules, monitoring and trust will keep it in use for the people who depend on it. That question has many answers, and some of the most durable were worked out by farmers and fishers long before economists arrived to explain why they could not succeed.
The ethics of the default
In 2008 the economist Richard Thaler and the legal scholar Cass Sunstein published Nudge, a book that gave governments a new vocabulary. Its central observation was that people's choices are shaped by how options are presented: which comes first on a list, which is labelled as standard, which requires a form to be filled in. Since some arrangement of choices is unavoidable, the authors argued, the designers of forms and policies might as well arrange them to help people do what they themselves would want on reflection. They called the approach libertarian paternalism: paternalist because it aims to improve people's welfare, libertarian because no option is forbidden and anyone may choose differently. The best-known example is the default. If employees are enrolled in a savings plan unless they opt out, far more of them end up saving than when they must actively opt in, even though the options available are identical. Few people object to the result. Yet the default raises a question that the cheerful examples tend to hide. If a nudge works precisely because people do not notice it, or cannot be bothered to resist it, in what sense does it respect their freedom? Defenders reply that there is no neutral alternative. A form must list its options in some order; a canteen must place some dishes at eye level. To refuse to nudge is not to leave people free but to let chance, habit or a commercial interest set the default instead. Seen this way, the only real choice is between nudging thoughtfully and nudging carelessly. The reply is strong but not complete. It shows that influence cannot be avoided; it does not show that every influence is equally legitimate. A useful test is whether a nudge could survive being announced. A government that automatically enrols people in a pension scheme, and tells them plainly that it has done so and how to leave, is acting in a way it can defend in public. A nudge that works only if no one realises it is happening is closer to manipulation, whatever its intentions. The difference is not between influence and freedom, since that contrast has already collapsed, but between influence that people could endorse if they understood it and influence that depends on their not understanding. This test will not settle every case. People who understand a default may still never get round to changing it, and transparency on paper is not the same as transparency in practice. But it shifts the debate to firmer ground. The question is no longer whether governments should shape choices, which they cannot avoid, but whether they are willing to do so openly.
Which of the following best captures the central argument of the passage?
According to the passage, the commons that lasted tended to have all of the following features EXCEPT
The author's remark that the herders in Hardin's parable "do not speak to one another" is meant to suggest that the parable
The author would most likely agree with which of the following statements about Ostrom's principles?
The last sentence of the passage is best described as
The passage is chiefly concerned with
According to the passage, Thaler and Sunstein called their approach libertarian because
Which of the following nudges would most clearly fail the test the author proposes?
The author regards the defenders' reply that "there is no neutral alternative" as
The paragraph below, about handwritten notes, is followed by four summaries. Choose the option that best captures the essence of the paragraph.
Supporters of handwritten notes often point out that writing by hand is slower than typing. The slowness, they argue, is the point: a student who cannot record every word must choose what to keep, and choosing requires understanding. Typing, by contrast, allows a student to transcribe a lecture almost word for word while thinking very little about it. If this is right, the advantage of the pen lies not in the pen itself but in the work of selection it forces, and a student who typed selectively would gain the same benefit.
The paragraph below, about scientific uncertainty, is followed by four summaries. Choose the option that best captures the essence of the paragraph.
Scientists are trained to state their uncertainty, and in a seminar the habit is a virtue. In public debate it can be turned into a weapon. Anyone who wishes to delay action on a problem can point to the qualifications in a scientific report and present them as proof that nothing is known. The difficulty is not that scientists are too honest, but that the public often hears uncertainty as ignorance, when it usually describes the range within which the answer lies. Explaining what that range is, and why action makes sense within it, may matter more than projecting false confidence.
The five sentences below, about why some queues cause anger, form a coherent paragraph when properly ordered. Choose the correct order.
1. The answer depends less on the length of the wait than on whether the wait seems fair. 2. That is why people will stand patiently in a long line that moves in order, yet grow furious in a shorter one where others push ahead. 3. Why do some queues produce calm and others rage? 4. Counters that switch to a single line feeding several windows often hear fewer complaints, even when the wait is no shorter. 5. Such a line removes the suspicion that one's own queue is the slow one, which is a large part of what people resent.
The five sentences below, about silence in conversation, form a coherent paragraph when properly ordered. Choose the correct order.
1. Each side reads the other's timing through its own habits and finds it wanting. 2. Elsewhere, the same pause suggests confusion or reluctance, and the listener rushes to fill it. 3. Silence in conversation is not empty; it is read, and different communities read it differently. 4. Misunderstandings between colleagues from different backgrounds often begin in such gaps. 5. In some settings, a pause before answering is a mark of respect: it shows that the question has been taken seriously.
Four of the five sentences below, about the design of streets, form a coherent paragraph. Which sentence is the odd one out?
1. A street designed for walking gives people reasons to linger: shade, benches, shop fronts close enough to look into. 2. Such streets tend to feel safer, because more eyes are on them at every hour. 3. Wide roads built for fast traffic, by contrast, empty the pavements and leave them to the few who have no choice. 4. Walking is also among the cheapest forms of exercise open to people who live in cities. 5. The design of a street, then, decides not only how people move but whether they stay.
What this set covers
- Reading comprehension: main idea2 questions
- Reading comprehension: detail2 questions
- Reading comprehension: inference2 questions
- Reading comprehension: author's view and tone2 questions
- Reading comprehension: application1 questions
- Para summary2 questions
- Para jumbles2 questions
- Odd sentence out1 questions
More practice for this exam
- Verbal ability and reading comprehension, set 214 questions · 25 min
- Verbal ability and reading comprehension, set 314 questions · 25 min
- Verbal ability and reading comprehension, set 414 questions · 25 min
- Verbal ability and reading comprehension, set 514 questions · 25 min
- CAT mock test 166 questions · 2 h
- CAT mock test 266 questions · 2 h
- VARC sectional test24 questions · 40 min
- DILR sectional test20 questions · 40 min
- Quant sectional test22 questions · 40 min
Independent practice. The Work Gym isn't affiliated with the IIMs or the CAT, and these aren't questions from past CAT papers.