CAT Verbal ability and reading comprehension practice, set 5
14 questions on verbal ability and reading comprehension at CAT pace: 25 min on the clock, or none if you want to study.
- Questions
- 14
- Time
- 25 min
- To pass
- 7 (50%)
- Part
- Verbal ability and reading comprehension
- Mode
- Timed or untimed
- Access
- Exam pass
The practice test needs JavaScript. These are its questions:
The sea star and the mussel bed
In the early 1960s the ecologist Robert Paine began a simple experiment on a stretch of rocky shore in Washington State. On one section of the shore he regularly prised off the ochre sea stars, predators that feed on mussels and other shellfish, and threw them back into the sea. A neighbouring section he left alone. The result overturned a common assumption. Removing a predator, one might expect, would allow its prey to flourish and the community to grow richer. Instead the cleared section grew poorer. Freed from the sea stars, mussels spread across the rock and crowded out barnacles, limpets, algae and other residents. Within a few years the number of species in the experimental area had fallen sharply, and the shore was on its way to becoming a single carpet of mussels. Paine described the sea star as a keystone species, borrowing the name of the wedge-shaped stone at the top of an arch that holds the others in place. The image was apt and, as images do, it travelled. Ecologists began to look for keystones elsewhere and found candidates: sea otters, whose appetite for sea urchins protects kelp forests; wolves, whose presence changes where elk graze; certain fig trees that feed a host of animals in seasons when little else bears fruit. The idea gave conservationists a powerful argument. If a few species do disproportionate work in holding a community together, protecting them yields benefits far beyond their own survival. Popularity, however, brought looseness. The term came to be applied to almost any species that seemed important, until critics complained that it had become a label of praise rather than a scientific claim. Part of the trouble is that keystone status is not a fixed property of a species. The same predator may hold a community together on one shore and matter little on another, where different prey, currents or temperatures prevail. To call a species a keystone is to say something about its relationship to a particular community at a particular time, and that relationship can be established only by careful observation or by experiments of the kind Paine performed, which are often impractical for large animals over large areas. Still, the deeper lesson of the sea star has survived the inflation of the word. It is easy to picture a living community as a pyramid built from the bottom up: plants and plankton capture the energy, and the animals above them simply take what is available. Paine's experiment showed, with unusual clarity, that influence also runs from the top down, and that the loss of a single consumer can reorganise everything beneath it. That insight, more than any list of keystones, is what changed the way ecologists look at a living community.
Numbers as targets
In 1975 the economist Charles Goodhart, writing about monetary policy in Britain, observed that a statistical regularity tends to break down once authorities start relying on it for control. The observation has since escaped economics and is usually quoted in a sharper form given to it in the 1990s by the anthropologist Marilyn Strathern: when a measure becomes a target, it ceases to be a good measure. The principle is now invoked wherever organisations manage by numbers, which is to say almost everywhere. The logic is easy to state. A measure is useful because it is correlated with something we care about but cannot observe directly. The number of patients seen in a day says something about a clinic's productivity; a student's examination mark says something about what the student has learned. As long as no one's fortunes depend on the number, the correlation holds. Once rewards and punishments are attached to it, people discover ways to raise the number that do not raise the underlying quality. Appointments are shortened, difficult patients are referred elsewhere, teaching narrows to what the examination asks. The figure improves, and the thing it was meant to reflect stays the same or gets worse. It is tempting to conclude that measurement itself is the enemy, and some critics of modern management come close to saying so. That conclusion is too quick. Without measures, organisations fall back on impressions, and impressions are no less open to gaming; they simply reward a different set of skills, such as charm or closeness to the people who judge. The choice is rarely between numbers and wisdom. It is between numbers used well and numbers used badly. Using them well involves a few habits that are easier to describe than to practise. One is to keep several measures in view at once, so that improving one at the expense of the others becomes visible. Another is to change the measures from time to time, before people have learned every way of moving them. A third, and the most important, is to treat a number as the beginning of a conversation rather than its end: to ask why a figure has moved before rewarding or punishing anyone for it. Each of these habits reduces the incentive to manipulate a measure by reducing the extent to which any single figure decides anyone's fate. Goodhart's insight, in other words, is not an argument against counting. It is a warning about what happens when counting replaces judgement instead of informing it.
Which of the following best summarises the passage?
According to the passage, what happened on the section of shore from which the sea stars were removed?
The passage suggests that critics objected to later uses of the term keystone chiefly because the term
Which finding would most directly support the claim that keystone status "is not a fixed property of a species"?
The examples of sea otters, wolves and fig trees serve mainly to
Which statement best summarises the author's view?
Which of the following is the clearest example of the process the passage describes?
The author argues that impressions are "no less open to gaming" in order to
According to the passage, the habits of using measures well work chiefly by
The paragraph below, about archives and historians, is followed by four summaries. Choose the option that best captures the essence of the paragraph.
Archives are often imagined as neutral stores of the past, waiting for historians to consult them. Yet every archive is the product of decisions about what was worth keeping, and those decisions were usually made by institutions with interests of their own. A colonial administration kept careful records of taxes collected and rebellions put down; it kept far fewer of the songs, quarrels and household budgets of the people it governed. The historian who reads such an archive must therefore read against its grain, attending to silences as closely as to statements, since what an archive leaves out is itself evidence of the power that shaped it.
The four sentences below, about apologies, form a coherent paragraph when properly ordered. Choose the correct order.
1. It is an admission that the speaker had a choice and chose badly. 2. A real apology, by contrast, names the act and accepts that it was wrong. 3. "I am sorry if anyone was offended" is not an apology but a comment on other people's feelings. 4. Such an admission is hard to make, which is precisely why it is valuable when it is made.
The four sentences below, about repair and skill, form a coherent paragraph when properly ordered. Choose the correct order.
1. Repairing a thing, by contrast, requires understanding how it works. 2. That understanding is a kind of knowledge that disappears when no one practises it. 3. Replacing a broken object requires only money. 4. A society that replaces everything may grow richer in goods and poorer in skill.
Four of the five sentences below, about the placebo response, form a coherent paragraph. Which sentence is the odd one out?
1. A patient who believes a treatment will help often reports feeling better, even when the treatment contains no active ingredient. 2. Some herbal remedies have been used in traditional medicine for many centuries. 3. This placebo response is one reason new drugs are tested against dummy pills rather than against nothing at all. 4. Researchers can then credit the drug only with the improvement that exceeds what the dummy pill produces. 5. Without such a comparison, the power of expectation would be mistaken for the power of chemistry.
Four of the five sentences below, about cities and rivers, form a coherent paragraph. Which sentence is the odd one out?
1. Many of the world's oldest cities grew up beside rivers. 2. A river offered drinking water, a route for trade and fertile soil on its floodplain. 3. The same river, however, could flood, and early settlers had to learn to live with its seasons. 4. Some modern cities have uncovered rivers that were once buried under roads. 5. The relationship between a city and its river was thus one of dependence mixed with danger.
What this set covers
- Reading comprehension: main idea2 questions
- Reading comprehension: detail2 questions
- Reading comprehension: inference1 questions
- Reading comprehension: strengthen or weaken1 questions
- Reading comprehension: function of a detail2 questions
- Reading comprehension: application1 questions
- Para summary1 questions
- Para jumbles2 questions
- Odd sentence out2 questions
More practice for this exam
- Verbal ability and reading comprehension, set 114 questions · 25 min
- Verbal ability and reading comprehension, set 214 questions · 25 min
- Verbal ability and reading comprehension, set 314 questions · 25 min
- Verbal ability and reading comprehension, set 414 questions · 25 min
- CAT mock test 166 questions · 2 h
- CAT mock test 266 questions · 2 h
- VARC sectional test24 questions · 40 min
- DILR sectional test20 questions · 40 min
- Quant sectional test22 questions · 40 min
Independent practice. The Work Gym isn't affiliated with the IIMs or the CAT, and these aren't questions from past CAT papers.